Eurypterid
Newsletter
Issue 1 (2001)
--Back to Newsletter
Home--
EDITORIAL
Welcome
to the first internet newsletter concerning those most spectacular
of fossils - the eurypterids. I would like to thank all of you
for providing information regarding your research interests. It
is good to see that research in these amazing arthropods is going
from strength-to-strength, and I look forward to reading about
the new taxa and data on eurypterid palaeoecology that is eluded
to in your contributions. I have deliberately kept the format
simple and excluded figures (to limit the size of the file). I
have also modified your contributions slightly (both to conform
to a standard format, make some of them a bit more concise, and
reduced relevant references to the 1990s).
I also hope that this newsletter will act as a focus
to discuss some of the outstanding issues in eurypterid research
(e.g. phylogeny etc.). In the next newsletter we could include
some short (e.g. 1000 word) contributions on some of the issues
that interest us (e.g. eurypterid phylogeny and their relationships
with scorpions - which appears to interest many of us).
Please continue to 'spread the word' amongst people
that you think will be interested in eurypterids, and invite contributions
(which can be e.mailed to me: <S.J.Braddy@bris.ac.uk>) for
the next newsletter - not just scientists but also collectors.
I hope that this newsletter can act as a focus to enable these
two groups to share information about recent discoveries (both
on our knowledge on the group, and new material). I will produce
the next newsletter when I receive a suitable number of new contributions.
Many
thanks
Dr
Simon J. Braddy
CONTRIBUTORS
Dr
Radek Mikulás
Ken Kinman
Professor
Ivo Chlupác
Dr Jason Dunlop
Simon Donato
Prof. Roy
E. Plotnick
Samuel J.
Ciurca, Jr.
Odd Erik Tetlie
Victor Tollerton
Dr Simon Braddy
Dr
Radek Mikulás
Contact
information: Institute of Geology, Academy of Sciences, Rozvojová
135, 165 00 Praha 6, Czech Republic. E.mail: <mikulas@gli.cas.cz>
Current
interests: Ichnofossils of the Paseky Shale (Lower Cambrian, Central
Bohemia) yield the oldest known non-marine or brackish assemblage
of macrofauna including eurypterids (Chlupác et al.
1995). The ichnoassemblage consists mostly of fodinichnia and
repichnia of endemic arthropods Kodymirus vagans Chlupác
& Havlicek, 1965 and Kockurus grandis Chlupác,
1995. These traces were attributed to ichnotaxa Monomorphichnus
biserialis Mikulás, 1995, M. semilineatus
Mikulás, 1995, M. multilineatus Alpert, 1976,
M. lineatus Crimes et al., 1977, M. bilinearis
Crimes, 1970, ?Rusophycus isp. A, ?R. isp.
B, ?Dimorphichnus isp., and Diplichnites isp.
Monomorphichnus biserialis is represented by two long
series of four to six grooves parallel to each other. Roughly
in a half of series, individual grooves intersect, so inner grooves
turn into outer ones and vice versa. Length of grooves up to 60
mm, spacings between them 1-3 mm. Kodymirus, as reconstructed
by Chlupác (1995), possibly produced these parallel striae
on the bottom by spines of prosomal appendages during more or
less active locomotion.
Relevant
references
Mikulás,
R. 1995. Trace fossils from the Paseky Shale (Early Cambrian,
Czech Republic). Jour. Czech Geol. Soc., 40/4,
37-45.
Return
to top
Ken
Kinman
Contact
information: E.mail: <kinman@hotmail.com>
Current
interests: I am very interested in eurypterid systematics at order
(and family) level. I had to make a decision (back in 1992-93)
whether or not to classify scorpions and eurypterids together,
as part of my general classification of organisms down to
ordinal level (The Kinman System, 1994). It was not an
easy decision, especially since the 1990 cladistic analysis of
Shultz (Cladistics, 6:1-38) showed the scorpions embedded well
within his arachnid "clade".
However,
I felt so strongly that scorpions are terrestrial descendants
of eurypterids, that I proposed a new Class Scorpionea for scorpions
and "sea-scorpions" (sensu lato). I divided Class
Scorpionea into 5 orders: Scorpionida (mostly terrestrial), Cyrtoctenida,
Pterygotida, Eurypterida, and Stylonurida. Today I might transfer
Orders Chasmataspida and Diploaspida from Xiphosurea to Scorpionea,
and perhaps make other changes. But the important thing was classifying
scorpions and "sea-scorpions" together, making it clear that they
are related and not just convergently similar. It also dramatically
reduced any possibility of a polyphyletic Class Arachnidea.
I
was therefore quite happy when Braddy et al. 1999 (Lethaia,
32:72-74) presented strong synapomorphic evidence
supporting an eurypterid-scorpion clade. It is clearly a
very important step in showing that a Class Scorpionea (or whatever
you wish to call it) should be recognized and placed between Class
Xiphosurea and Class Arachnidea.
Relevant
references
"The
Kinman System" (1994) was published (but not in hardcover).
In the UK there are not many public copies - University of Glasgow
was the first, and I believe the copy that went through Blackwell's
last year went to the British Library. Most public copies are
in the US (Library of Congress, Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Cornell,
and various other university libraries).
Return
to top
Professor
Ivo Chlupác
Contact
information: Institute of Geology and Palaeontology, Department
of Natural Sciences, Charles University, Albertov 6, 128 43 Praha
2, Czech Republic.
Current interests: Bohemian eurypterids. The oldest
eurypterid from the classical Barrandian area of Central Bohemia
(Czech Republic) derives from the Lower Cambrian Paseky Shale.
It is Kodymirus vagans Chlupác et Havlicek, 1965
(recently found also with appendages) accompanied by possibly
allied Kockurus grandis Chlupác, 1995. These remains come
probably from non-marine (brackish) environment. The Ordovician
remains are problematic, the Silurian eurypterids are represented
within the Ludlow and particularly in the Prídolí,
where the giant Acutiramus bohemicus (Barrande, 1872)
is the most characteristic (it attains the calculated total length
up to 2.3 to 2.5 m). Other Late Silurian species (rare): Acutiramus?
nobilis (Barrande, 1872), Pterygotus barrandei Semper,
1898, P. kopaninensis Barrande, 1872, Paracarcinosoma
accrocephala (Semper,
1898) and Slimonia? sp. The earliest Devonian
(Lochkovian) species include Acutiramus perneri Chlupác,
1994, Slimonia? sp. and Paracarcinosoma
sp. All are found in typical marine, mostly basinal environment
together with graptolites, brachiopods and other fossils.
Relevant
references
Chlupác,
I. 1994. Pterygotid eurypterids (Arthropoda, Chelicerata) in the
Silurian and Devonian of Bohemia. Jour. Czech Geol. Soc.,
39, 2-3, 147-162.
Chlupác, I. 1995. Lower Cambrian arthropods
from the Paseky Shale (Barrandian area, Czech Republic). Jour.
Czech Geol. Soc., 40/4, 9-36.
Chlupác, I., Kraft, J., & Kraft, P. 1995.
Geology of fossil sites with the oldest Bohemian fauna (Lower
Cambrian, Barrandian area). Jour. Czech Geol. Soc, 40/4,
1 8
Chlupác, I. 1997. Early Devonian eurypterids
with Barrandian affinities from Catalonia (NE Spain). Batalleria,
7, 9-21.
Chlupác, I. 1999. Some problematical arthropods
from the Upper Ordovician Letná Formation of Bohemia. Jour.
Czech Geol. Soc., 44, 1-2, 79-91.
Return
to top
Dr
Jason Dunlop
Contact
information: Insitut für Systematische Zoologie, Museum für
Naturkunde der Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, Invalidenstraße
43, D-10115 Berlin, Germany. Email: <jason.dunlop@rz.hu-berlin.de>
www: <http://members.tripod.com/~DrJasonDunlop/index.html>
Current
interests: Currently working with Simon Braddy (Bristol) on whether
eurypterids form a monophyletic group and on their position within
the Chelicerata.
Eurypterids resemble scorpions in overall appearance,
hence the name 'sea scorpions', but does this reflect their phylogeny
or is it a case of convergent evolution and/or mimicry between
them? Three principal phylogenetic models have been proposed in
the literature: 1. The traditional Merostomata concept (i.e.
Eurypterida + Xiphosura). 2. Weygoldt and Paulus's Metastomata
hypothesis (i.e. Eurypterida + Arachnida). 3. A controversial
Scorpionomorpha hypothesis (i.e. Eurypterida + Scorpiones).
Comparative
morphological studies between eurypterids, especially those from
Konservatt-Lagerstätte showing exceptional preservation,
and the other chelicerates are yielding new characters which we
are testing in cladistic analyses. Under some parameters eurypterids
and scorpions emerge as sister taxa, mostly supported by gross
morphological characters, but other data (see papers by Jeff Shultz,
Maryland) places scorpions among the remaining arachnids with
eurypterids holding a more basal position.
Other
interests: 1. History of eurypterid research. 2. Eurypterid functional
morphology and systematics. 3. Relationships between eurypterids
and the similar-looking fossil group Chasmataspida.
Relevant
references:
Dunlop,
J. A. 1998. The origins of tetrapulmonate book lungs and their
significance for chelicerate phylogeny. Proceedings of the
17th European Colloquium of Arachnology, Edinburgh, 1997,
9-16.
Dunlop, J. A. & Webster, M. 1999. Fossil evidence,
terrestrialisation and arachnid phylogeny. The Journal of
Arachnology, 27, 86-93.
Braddy, S. J. and Dunlop, J. A. 2000. Early Devonian
eurypterids from the Northwest Territories of Arctic Canada. Canadian
Journal of Earth Science, 37, 1167-1175.
Return
to top
Simon
Donato
Contact
information: Department of Earth Science, University of Western
Ontario, London, ON, Canada. E.mail < sdonato@julian.uwo.ca>
Current
research: A new eurypterid genus from the Upper Ordovician Georgian
Bay Formation of Manitoulin Island. Excavations by University
of Western Ontario graduate students in May of 2000, revealed
a rich assemblage of well-preserved eurypterid remains immediately
below an unconformity marking the Ordovician-Silurian boundary
(uppermost Georgian Bay Formation) south-west of Little Current,
Manitoulin Island. Hosting sediments grade from finely crystalline
argillaceous dolostone to poorly lithified silty clay in a vertical
sequence of approximately 30 cm. Preliminary investigations
suggest that the eurypterid specimens represent a new genus, and
is also the oldest known occurrence of eurypterids in Canada.
The chitinous eurypterid remains are very well preserved, and
almost all body parts appear to be present. The remains
were restricted to a very small area and are disarticulated. Two
nearly complete specimens were recovered. Tentative habitat
reconstruction points to a poorly circulated tropical shallow
marine shelf environment.
Return
to top
Prof.
Roy E. Plotnick
Contact
information: Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences, University
of Illinois at Chicago, 845 W. Taylor St., Chicago, IL 60607,
U.S.A. E.mail: <plotnick@uic.edu>. Web: <http//www.uic.edu/depts/geos/plotnick.htm>
Current
interests: I have a number of undescribed specimens that I will
get to at some point in time (hopefully, soon). These include
a Megalograptus from the Ordovician of Virginia and a
Cyrtoctenus-like form from the Carboniferous of Virginia,
as well as some Devonian pterygotid and stylonurid material from
Michigan. I am also planning to carry out a cladistic analysis
of the Late Paleozoic eurypterids.
Relevant
references:
Plotnick,
R. 1990. Evolution of the arthropod cuticle. pp. 177-196 IN Mikulic,
D., ed., Arthropod Paleobiology. Short Courses in Paleontology,
number 3.
Plotnick, R. 1990. Eurypterids. McGraw-Hill
Encyclopedia of Science and Technology, 7th ed.
Plotnick , R. and Elliott, D. 1995. A Lower Devonian
stylonurid eurypterid from Arctic Canada. Journal of Paleontology,
69:399-401.
Plotnick, R. 1996. The scourge of the Silurian seas.
American Paleontologist, 4(1):2-3.
Plotnick, R. 1997. Eurypterids. p. 208-210
IN Shabica, C. and A. Hay (eds.) Richardson's Guide
to the Fossil Fauna of Mazon Creek. Northeastern Illinois University.
Plotnick, R. 1999. Llandoverian-Lochkovian eurypterid
communities. P. 106-131. IN: Boucot, A. and J. Lawson (eds.)
Paleocommunities: A Case Study from the Silurian and Lower
Devonian. Cambridge University Press
Return
to top
Samuel
J. Ciurca, Jr.
Contact
information: 54 Appleton Street, Rochester, New York, USA. Email:
<paleoresearch@yahoo.com>
Current
interests: Eurypterids, sedimentary structures and the paleoenvironment
of the late Silurian Williamsville waterlime (Bertie Group) Ontario,
Canada and western New York State. Current research includes the
additional collection of hundreds of eurypterid specimens for
a detailed analysis of the eurypterid and associated fauna and
flora - including new eurypterids not reported previously from
this well-known horizon.
In
addition, the first survey of the sedimentary structures is being
completed. These have heretofore not been generally accessible
in plane view. Notable is the occurrence of "boomerangs," large
sedimentary structures interpreted as being generated by swift
currents
that scoured the surface of Williamsville (A). To date, over 100
of these structures have been mapped on a grid consisting of 25
square meter squares. A preliminary description of the discovery
of these "boomerangs" and other observations was published previously
(New York State Geological Association Guidebook, 1994).
Also,
a site has been discovered that yields abundant Late Silurian
plants, including Cooksonia sp. and Medusaegraptus sp. The eurypterids,
sedimentary structures, and the Late Silurian flora mentioned
above, all occur within the Williamsville (A) Waterlime, about
20 inches thick, within a thick sequence of mostly dolomitic rocks
termed the Bertie Group (Type section: Bertie Township, Ontario,
Canada).
Relevant
references
Accounts
(abstracts) of two projects are being published in the near future
by the Rochester Academy of Science.
Return
to top
Odd
Erik Tetlie
Contact
information: Paleontologisk Museum, Universitetet i Oslo, Oslo,
Norway. E.mail: <o.e.tetlie@nhm.uio.no>
Current
interests: Early diversification and phylogeny of chelicerates,
phylogeny and taxonomy of eurypterids. Material presently under
investigation: A fourth specimen of Paleomerus hamiltoni
from the Lower Cambrian of Sweden. The Silurian eurypterids and
other chelicerates found at Rudstangen, Norway. Some arthropod
trackways previously unknown from Rudstangen, Norway. Some early
Devonian eurypterids and chasmataspids from Alken, Germany. PMO's
scattered collection of eurypterids from Scotland, the USA and
Gotland.
Relevant
references:
Tetlie,
O.E. 2000: Eurypterids from the Silurian of Norway. Unpublished
MSc thesis. 152 pp. [the results from the thesis will be presented
in 2 or 3 papers in the near future]
Tetlie, O.E. 2000: A 410 million years old sea scorpion
from Ringerike. T¯yen Highlights. 44-45.
Tetlie, O.E. (in press): Norwegian eurypterids [in
Norwegian]. Stein.
Return
to top
Victor
Tollerton
Contact
information: 23 Shepherd Place, Utica, New York 13502-5417. Email:
<mtolrton@borg.com>
Current
research: My unpublished Master's thesis (from SUNY at Buffalo
in 1992) dealt with the comparitive ontogeny of Eurypterus lacustris
and Eurypterus remipes. I'm still obtaining data for eventual
publication of my thesis. My current work inclcudes the description
of a new species of Acutiramus from the Devonian? of
New York State, and a new genus of eurypterid from the Silurian
of New York State and Ontario, Canada. Two longer term projects
include an annotated bibliography and index of the Eurypterida,
and a paper intended to be a revision of the eurypterid parts
of both the Treatise, and the Fossilium Catalogus. Unfortunately,
both projects are going slow. I'm also doing some work on a cladistic
analysis, and on the world-wide distribution of eurypterids on
available paleogeographic maps.
For
some years now, I've been re-studying the Ordovician eurypterids
of New York State, most of which were originally described by
R. Ruedemann. In essence, my results are that with two exceptions
(and one of those is a phyllocarid) all the specimens are inorganic
sedimentary structures. I have also discovered a plausible
and possible reason for Ruedemann's "error". I believe he
had an eye condition known as strabismus, and as a consequence
of this he was not able to see as well in three dimensions as
individuals without this condition. My research on Ruedemann continues.
I'd
like to ask some questions of the readers of the newsletter.
Has anyone beside myself and Rick Batt of Buffalo, New York, collected
eurypterids in situ? If they have, have they noted the prevalence
for the eurypterids to be situated so that they are on their backs?
I've noted this condition at two eurypterid localities in New
York State, and one in West Virginia (at Bass), while Rick has
observed this condition at localities in Ontario, Canada.
As a topic for discussion in the newsletter, I think this condition
is in agreement with Simon's hypothesis of mass mate-moult occurrences.
What would the readers of the newsletter think about establishing
a specimen bank of eurypterid cuticles? I'll leave cladistics
for the next newsletter.
Relevant
references:
My
bibliography includes a classification of the Order Eurypterida,
published in 1989 in the Journal of Paleontology.
Return
to top
Dr
Simon Braddy
Contact
information: Department of Earth Sciences, University of Bristol,
Wills Memorial Building, Queen's Road, Bristol, BS8 1RJ. UK. E.mail:
<S.J.Braddy@bris.ac.uk>
Current
research: My research on the eurypterids is primarily concerned
with their functional morphology and palaeobiology (reproduction,
respiration and locomotion (particularly walking biomechanics,
involving computer modelling and analysis of trackway data). I
continue to work on exceptionally preserved Onychopterella
material from the late Ordovician Soom Shale Lagerstätte
of South Africa. I am investigating the palaeophysiology of eurypterid
respiration and the functional morphology of pteygotid eurypterid
chelicerae (with Stephen Rawlinson; ex-MSc Bristol). I am also
interested in eurypterid palaeoecology (and have proposed a ‘Mass-Moult-Mate’
hypothesis; under revision for P3) and phylogeny, particularly
of carcinsomatids (and the probable link with scorpions; with
Jason Dunlop) and chasmataspids (which on recent evidence appear
to be sister-group with Eurypterida).
Relevant
recent references:
Braddy,
S. J., Aldridge, R. J. and Theron, J. N. 1995. A new eurypterid
from the Late Ordovician Table Mountain Group, South Africa, Palaeontology,
38, 563-581.
Braddy, S. J. and Anderson, L. I. 1996. An Upper
Carboniferous eurypterid trackway from Mostyn, Wales. Proceedings
of the Geologists’ Association, 107, 51-56.
Braddy, S. J. and Dunlop, J. A. 1997. The functional
morphology of mating in the Silurian eurypterid, Baltoeurypterus
tetragonophthalmus (Fischer, 1839). The Zoological Journal
of the Linnean Society, 121, 435-461.
Dunlop, J. A., and Braddy, S. J. 1997. Slit-like
structures on the prosomal appendages of the eurypterid Baltoeurypterus,
Neues Jahrbuch Für Geologie und Paläontologie, Monatshefte,
1, 31-38.
Braddy, S. J. 1998. Arthropod trackways from South
Africa. Geoscientist, 8(7), 4-6.
Braddy, S. J. and Milner, A. R. C. 1998. A large
arthropod trackway from the Gaspé Sandstone Group (Middle
Devonian) of eastern Canada. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences,
35, 1116-1122.
Draganits, E., Grasemann, B. and Braddy, S. J. 1998.
Discovery of giant arthropod trackways in the Devonian Muth Quartzite
(Spiti, India): implications for the depositional environment.
Journal of Asian Earth Sciences, 16 (2-3),
109-118.
Braddy, S. J. Aldridge, R. J., Gabbott, S. E. and
Theron, J. N. 1999. Lamellate book-gills in a late Ordovician
eurypterid from the Soom Shale Lagerstätte, South Africa:
support for a eurypterid-scorpion clade. Lethaia,
32, 72-74.
Braddy, S. J. and Almond, J. 1999. Eurypterid trackways
from the Table Mountain Group (Lower Ordovician) of South Africa.
Journal of African Earth Sciences, 29 (1),
165-177.
Braddy, S. J. 2000. Eurypterids from the Lower Devonian
of the Midland Valley of Scotland. Scottish Journal of Geology,
36 (2), 115-122.
Braddy, S. J. and Dunlop, J. A. 2000. Lower Devonian
eurypterids from the Northwest Territories of Arctic Canada. Canadian
Journal of Earth Sciences, 37, 1167-1175.
Burrow, C. J., Braddy, S. J., and Douglas, J. In
press. Pterygotid eurypterid chelicera from the Siluro-Devonian
of Victoria. Alcheringa.
Draganits, E., Braddy, S. J., and Briggs, D. E.
G. In press. A Gondwanan coastal arthropod ichnofauna from the
Muth Formation (Lower Devonian, Northern India): paleoenvironment
and tracemaker behaviour. Palaios.
Return
to top
--Back
to Newsletter Home--